1
General Discussion / Re: Kinect on E3 and the future
« on: June 25, 2011, 09:49:04 AM »I can only speak for myself, but I have only rarely seen Vox respond to ambient commands and I have had a microphone very close to speakers. It is possible of course, but my experience is it is not as big a problem as one may expect.
I too have used a regualr mic with fairly good results, but even one false command can ruin the experience, and I recieved quite a few unwanted pauses, track skips and so on. I also had to shout quite loud to make my commands heard.
Quote
It looks like there is some potential for the Kinect, but if you don't already have one, I think the Amulet is still going to be the winner. The Kinect might be more "fun" to use at first, but in terms of a home theatre setup, the Amulet is just much more practical. Also, I can take my Amulet out onto the deck with me. Unless you already own a Kinect, the price is comparable.
I don't know much about the amulet remote but I understand it is a remote with a mic in? Maybe im missing something, but for me the benefits of something like vox commando is to take the remote out of the equation. If I have to carry a remote around with me to make commands, I may as well press the buttons!
Obviously I get that even having to hold a remote VC offers a great shortcut for many commands and is more fun to use, but I think the goal of the software would be to allow a user to make complely natural voice commands with no peripherals on their person. I think that James would agree that this would be the ultimate. Its a shame that kinect is not a fast track solution to that as I think many hoped it would be as it was seemingly designed with this use in mind, however I have hope that further experimentation with the device will unlock new possibilities (paticularly with the gesture commands working in parallel).
All I can do is wish James luck, and look forward to a later release after some experierimentation with kinect with some optimism,